Apple Pest Report
Monday, June 14, 2004
Vol. 12 No. 4

 

 

 Scab

How much protection is needed until scab control can be verified?


    The final scab ascospore release in Sanford was June 1.   The season's final primary scab ascospore release in Monmouth (Highmoor Farm) and in Gorham was on Wednesday, June 9.  While there is a statistical possibility of a few straggler ascospores still being around for release with the next rain, the ascospore infection potential at these locations is minimal at the worst, and probably zero.

     The situation is quite different for locations the did not get rain on June 6 - 9.  In Old Town, the final primary scab infection period of the season will arrive with the next warm (over 50F), soaking (over 0.1"), daytime (between 8am and 7pm) rain (possibly Tuesday June 15)..  Usually the season's final primary infection period is a whimper as the last bit of straggler ascospores are released.  Because of the lack of daytime since June 2, about 9% of the season's ascospore load remains to be released in the Old Town area.  As a result, the final primary infection period for locations that did not get daytime rain on June 6 - 9 could carry a greater than usual infection potential.

     Even after ascospore releases are finished, attention still needs to be given to scab management until you can verify success.  That requires looking for, and not finding, scab lesions. 

     A scab lesion is a colony of spore producing structures growing out of an infected leaf.  If fungicide protection was adequate during the April - early June infection periods, then there will be so few spore producing colonies that you can safely switch the focus of disease control away from scab and onto flyspeck. 

     There is a 9-17 day lag period between a primary scab infection period and when infections become visible as they start producing a new generation of spores.  Lesions from the season's final ascospore releases in Sanford will have had time to become visible by June 18.  The equivalent dates in Monmouth and Old Town are June 22 and June 26.

     But even then the risk of scab infection is still not completely known, at least in orchards with trees over 10 feet tall.  Fungicide protection is usually less, and thus scab infection potential is greater, in the tops of tall trees.  And just a few primary scab lesions, each producing about 40,000 spores over their 4 week lifetime, are enough to cause an economically significant degree of fruit infection.  So in taller trees, you can't really be sure that scab was adequately controlled until enough time has passed for 1st generation lesions to spread inoculum for 2nd generation lesions, and then enough time has passed for those infections to become visible.  Thus, with tall trees it isn't until almost a month after the final ascospore release that you can confirm successful primary (ascospore) scab control. 

     The dates for final 2nd generation lesion appearance can't be accurately predicted yet because doing so requires knowing the date of the first rain after all 1st generation lesions have appeared.  But we can make reasonable guesses.

     Here is a table to help keep the dates straight:

Site 99+% ascospore release 1st generation lesions from final ascospore release visible 2nd generation lesions from final ascospore release visible
Sanford June 1 June 18 ca, June 29
Monmouth June 9 June 22 ca. July 4
Gorham June 9 June 22 ca. July 4
Old Town June 15 June 27 ca. July 9

 

      What is the appropriate management strategy during this transition period after after the end of scab ascospore releases and before confirming successful scab control? 

     Should you maintain solid fungicide protection even though there may not be any 1st or 2nd generation lesions to produce spores?  Is is safe to let fungicide coverage lapse and just be ready to retreat quickly if scab lesions are found?  What's the middle ground between these two extremes? 

     The problem with the "keep spraying" approach is that it makes scab season last another 4 weeks after the end of ascospore releases.  You are getting paid to grow fruit, not spray fungicides.  The problem with the "relax and wait" approach is that unless you are checking the orchard daily and can treat as soon as any lesions appear before rain spreads infections to other leaves and fruit, you could be allowing a scab epidemic to build up momentum and fruit damage before you can react.    

     There is no single answer because the proper approach is situation dependent.  There are three objectives you want from a fungicide applied between the end of ascospore releases and the date when you can confirm that scab control was effective:
  
1) reduce spore production on any scab lesions that develop
   2) protect leaves and fruit from potential secondary scab infections
   3) protect against other diseases - primarily flyspeck (more on summer diseases below).
 
     So if you have not fallen asleep already, keep reading for some thoughts intended to help you choose the appropriate degree of protection needed in this interim period.  Please note, what follows are suggestions to consider, not research validated guidelines!

Scab situation Fungicide Interval

1) Using sulfur only

     Continue reapplying before any potential infection period (= any rain period that will keep leaves wet for more than 6 contiguous hours) that will last beyond 5 days or 0.5" rain since the previous sulfur application.
 

2) Unacceptable scab infestation last year, using captan, or
sterol inhibitor + captan, or
strobilurin fungicide this year

    Use primary scab season intervals until scouting confirms absence of 2nd generation scab lesions. 
    For captan - 7 days or 2" rain, whichever comes first. 
    For SI+half rate captan - 6 days or 1" rain. 
    For strobilurin - 6 days, up to 3" rain.
 

3) More scab than you would like last year (but well below 10% of fruit affected),  primary scab fungicide protection this spring was solid (no missed infection  periods, postinfection applications either not needed or always made within the 72 hour postinfection window).
OR
     Good scab control last year, but some potential lapses or late postinfection sprays this spring

     For captan or SI-captan combination - 14 days or 2" rain.
     For strobilurin - 12 days or 3" rain.

4) Good scab control last year (well below 1% fruit affected), solid protection during primary scab infection periods this spring.

     Use fungicide interval advised for flyspeck suppression.
     For full dose captan - 21 days or 2.5" rain. 
     For strobilurin 21 days or 3.5" rain.  
 

5) Scab index done to confirm low scab status last fall,
    no doubt about solid protection during primary scab infections this spring,
    and relatively open well-pruned trees without past flyspeck problems, and without brambles growing in tree rows to provide an in-orchard supply of flyspeck spores.

     With continued checking for scab lesions at least once a week, it seems reasonably safe to wait to resume fungicide coverage when the next spray trip is needed for other reasons, even if this means that coverage lapses before that date.
     The timing for next spray will probably be determined by increased flyspeck threat or apple maggot. 
     Flyspeck threat increases when there is potential for 2nd generation flyspeck spores (estimated dates Sanford - July 2, Gorham&Monmouth - July 8-10, Old Town - July 18.). 
     Need for first apple maggot spray can be monitored with sticky sphere traps.
 

    

     How many scab lesions at this time of the year is enough to call for eradication treatments? 
    

Procedure and interpretation for Scab inspection

scout cartoonPROCEDURE: 

        As a bare minimum, check 100 fruit clusters or vegetative shoots per block.  Select the cluster/shoots from tree at least 10 trees per block.  Your sample of fruit clusters and vegetative shoots should come from at least 10 trees per block (i.e. no more than 10 per tree).  Checking 5 clusters/shoots per tree on 20 trees is even better.  Randomly select clusters and shoots from all areas of the canopy.  Problems due to improper spray distribution can be limited to one section of the tree. 

 

Inspecting a block for scab requires looking at a lot of leaves.  In order to do that you don't have time to study each leaf, but instead do a quick "photographic flash" of about 15 leaves at a time.  You have to look at each cluster twice, once for the upper leaf surface and again for the underside.  By looking at about 15 leaves per cluster/shoot on 100 clusters/shoots, you will be checking about 1500 leaves.

 

Don't try to scout for other pests at the same time.  If you need to check for other pests, do it separately from the scab scouting, either as a separate visit or on the same visit but as a separate walk through the block.  To check 100 samples per block for scab takes about 30 minutes of walking and focused gazing.  It is not a stroll through the orchard, it is work.  But it is work worth doing.

 

A small hand clicker-counter held that leaves your hands free to grab shoots is useful to keep track of the number of shoots and clusters checked.  When you find a leaf with one or more scab lesions, put it in your pocket.  When the clicker reaches 100, stop and count the number of scabby leaves you have collected. 

 

 

INTERPRETATION:    

            It is impossible to devise a threshold number of infected leaves for two reasons.  Because of differences in tree size, orchard operation, marketing, cultivar, site characteristics etc., there is a unique context for evaluating the level of scab infection in each orchard.  And the relationship between scab lesions appearing shortly after petal fall and the consequences in terms of fruit infection at harvest is not understood well enough to provide a specific, reliable threshold.  With that caution in mind, a threshold of 0.5% of leaves infested (i.e. 8 infested leaves out of 1500 leaves checked) has been suggested by pathologists as a reasonable guess at a threshold for suppression treatments. 

 

The Fall Scab Indexing procedure which is part of the Delayed-First-Spray strategy (see page 13 of the 2003-2004 New England Apple Pest Management Guide) is also built around detecting scab infestation of 0.5% of the leaves.  Even though it is a tool built for a different purpose, we can use it as an interpretive guideline for June scab lesion scouting. 

  

If you find less than 5 scab-infested leaves per 100 fruit clusters & vegetative shoots, this suggests with a reasonable degree of confidence that protection during primary (ascospore) scab infection periods was adequate.

 

Conversely, if you find 18 or more scab-infested leaves per 100 clusters and shoots, that can be taken as evidence that lesion suppression is needed.  We used to call that ‘eradication’, but that terminology is misleading because you are not able to completely stop spore production on 100% of the lesions.

 

If the number of scab-infested leaves per 100 clusters/shoots is between 5 and 18, you can either increase the sample to see if a clear result comes out, or quit sampling and identify the degree of scab infestation as intermediate.  If do increase the sample size, the procedure calls for adding another 100 shoots/clusters from across the block and adding the number of scabbed leaves found in the second 100 shoots/clusters to the number found in the first 100.  For a combined 200 cluster/shoot sample, finding less than 12 scab infested leaves indicates adequate control.  Finding more than 24 infested leaves indicates need for eradication.

 

If you need eradication treatments, what are the best fungicide options?

     The New England Apple Pest Management Guide rates sterol inhibitors, Syllit, and Topsin as the only fungicides with postsymptom activity.  This means those materials have the ability to reduce spore production from scab lesions that develop.  But as usual, it's not quite that simple. 

     In orchards where scab tolerance/resistance has developed to any of these materials, the postsymptom activity will be diminished or nonexistent.  And if resistance is not present, use of these materials for postsymptom control will increase the chance of resistant scab strains being selected. 

     The sterol inhibitors don't offer protection for summer diseases, don't provide very good fruit protection, and only provide 3-4 days of forward protection against scab on leaves.  While they do have postsymptom activity against existing lesions, SIs are only rated fair to good in that regard.  The one situation where sterol inhibitor would be the best choice at this point in the season is if you are dealing with powdery mildew.  But it is unlikely that any Maine apple grower is dealing with powdery mildew this year given the low winter temperatures we had over the winter.  So if you do find active scab lesions, rather than risk resistance, it seems better to save the SIs for their valuable postinfection activity against primary scab in future years.

     Syllit will help shut down active lesions, but it doesn't offer much protection for flyspeck and other summer diseases.  Topsin M does provide activity against flyspeck and black rot and is rated very good for postsymptom control.  Both Syllit and Topsin M have resistance concerns.   Topsin M is cross-resistant with Benlate.  So where Benlate or Topsin were used frequently in the past, Topsin M may not be effective.

     Wouldn't it be great if you didn't have to guess at the resistance status in your orchard?  If you find scab lesions, you can have them tested for resistance to a variety of fungicides through a reasonably priced service offered by Research and Development Institute for the Agri-Environment in Quebec.  The turn around time won't be fast enough to inform your decisions this year, but would be useful knowledge for future decisions. 

     Five resistance tests are available: 
1) strobilurins (Flint, Sovran);
2) sterol inhibitors (Nova, Procure, Rubigan); 3) Syllit; 4) Topsin M; and 5) Vangard.  Once the lab sets up to handle a sample, it is cheaper to run multiple tests for a sample, so the price for each additional test decreases.  The pricing is as follows:     
1 test =    $ 90
2 tests = $ 160
3 test =   $ 210
4 tests = $ 240
5 tests = $ 250

     Contact me if you find scab lesions and are interested in getting them tested.

    

     There are two other options to consider, and both are probably preferable to the ones mentioned above.  Captan does not do much to reduce spore production from lesions, but it is a great protectant to keep secondary spores from being able to initiate infections on leaves and fruit.  Captan combined with some hot dry weather is as good as it gets for scab "eradication".  Of course you can't control the weather, but full strength captan regardless of the weather is almost as good as you can do.

     The other alternative is even better, though also more expensive:  a strobilurin + half-dose captan combination.  The strobilurin's ability to bind with the waxy cuticle on fruit over 1 cm diameter may provide better residual protection against wash-off by heavy rains. This idea has not been fully tested and validated, but it makes sense.  The captan in this combination provides additional protection, including redistribution during rain, and acts as a second barrier to forestall selecting for scab resistance to the strobilurin. 

     You might think that strobilurin alone would be a good option, but results from applying Flint or Sovran onto existing scab lesions have been mixed and often less than satisfactory.  And strobilurins do not have the ability to stop spore production from visible lesions.  If applied just before a lesion appears, they do seem to significantly reduce spore production.  But good luck trying to time a spray to make optimum use of that ability.  And of course, applying strobilurin alone onto existing lesions is what you would do if you wanted to breed resistant scab.

     Dr. Dave Rosenberger is recommending that New York growers needing to eradicate scab lesions apply full dose captan, followed by a full strength strobilurin + half dose captan combination. 

     My assumption is that the second spray is to be made about 10-14 days after the first, or after the captan residue has been depleted by 1.5 to 2 inches rain.  Whether a third application is needed on a shorter interval for scab control than would be used for flyspeck protection will depend on cultivar sensitivity to scab, the number of fresh active scab lesions at that time, and the amount of new foliage growth.  Once terminal bud set occurs, the momentum of a scab outbreak decreases due to the absence of tender new foliage to host new infections.

 

 Flyspeck and other 'Summer diseases'  

     If you control flyspeck, then you have done enough to control sooty blotch fungi.  The other two summer diseases of some consequence in Maine orchards are black rot and bitter rot. Unless there is either unusually hot, humid weather or an unusually high amount of inoculum (such as dead trees left in the orchard), a fungicide program designed for flyspeck will also keep black rot and bitter rot from becoming problems. 

     Black rot fruit infections are usually found on older trees where a branch canker is dropping spores onto underlying fruit.  While it manifests as leaf and fruit infections, black rot is probably more important for the branch cankers it can cause.  Black rot infection is facilitated by winter damage, which is in plentiful supply in Maine orchards this year.  Removing dead and dying wood will help keep black rot and opportunistic wood rot fungi from taking advantage of a free food supply in the orchard. 

     Bitter rot is rarely a problem in Maine, presumably because it likes hotter temperatures than Maine usually provides.  But it has been found causing fruit infections in Maine orchards in the past.


 Insects and Mites

    Plum curculio burst out of their slumber with a night of passionate egglaying on Wednesday, June 9.  With the return of cool temperatures Thursday - Sunday June 10 - 13 I assume they slowed down again, but I don't have data to confirm that.  I only mention the recent cool weather because it could have caused a stall in PC egglaying that will be released with warm weather forecast for Tuesday through Saturday.

     The 340 degree day (base 50F) plum curculio control window at Highmoor Farm is forecast to end around Sunday June 27.  Thus, a border row or full block insecticide application made on or after June 13 should last long enough to cover the remaining part of the control window, barring a major rain before June 27 to deplete coverage beforehand.

     The final PC spray dates in Sanford, Gorham, and Old Town are June 7, June 12, and June 16.

     European red mites may be making a come back.  Over threshold populations have already been found in Scouting Coop blocks, and increased ERM populations have been reported elsewhere in the Northeast.  The threshold from June 15 to July 16 is if more than 54% of middle aged fruit cluster or vegetative shoot leaves have living hatched mites present, or if the average number of mites per leaf exceeds 2.5.  Don't be lulled to sleep if you check for mites in the next week and find none.  The apparent ERM population drops every year around this time as first generation adults are dying of old age and second generation nymphs have not yet started hatching.  An important time to check for mites is just before second generation nymphs reach maturity and begin laying third generation eggs.  The date for that blessed event is expected to be around June 21 in Sanford, June 27-29 in Monmouth/Gorham, and July 3 in Old Town.

     If mite control is needed, even though it's too late to expect residual control from Agri-Mek, one of the early season primarily ovicidal materials (Apollo, Savey, or Zeal) might still be a good choice.  Vendex and Kelthane are still viable alternatives.  You might want to save Pyramite and Acramite for late summer rescue if needed.  Danitol is a pyrethroid that while harsh on beneficial arthropods, does offer relatively inexpensive dual insecticidal and miticidal activity.

 

 Weeds

Mid-June to mid-July is the most effective timing for controlling persistent weeds like bindweed, brambles, dandelion, goldenrod, and vetch with Gramoxone (paraquat) or Rely (glufosinate).
    

 Other stuff

1) The weather this week is conducive for good thinner activity, but the thinning window ends when fruit reach 18mm diameter.

 

2) The EPA is concerned about implementation of Worker Protection rules.  Inspection activity could intensity this summer, and EPA is especially interested checking apple orchards for compliance.  Henry Jennings of the Maine Board of Pesticides Control provided  the following synopsis:

* EPA is especially concerned with migrant workers
* They expect the state to fine growers who aren't pretty much up to snuff
* Make sure workers  been trained within 5 years
* Have a Safety Poster, a list of pesticide applications and the emergency medical facility contact information at a central location accessible to the workers
* Have water, soap and single use towels available within 1/4 mile of where workers are working
* Observe the REIs
* Notify workers and handlers when fields have been sprayed
* Provide handlers with a clean place to change and wash-up and maintain the PPE properly

     I'll have more details in the next issue.
.

 

3) Position Announcement - Farm Superintendent - Highmoor Farm, Monmouth, Maine

The Farm Superintendent supervises and manages Highmoor Farm as a research facility for conducting field experiments planned and directed by scientists of the Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station and the University of Maine Cooperative Extension. Housing for the Superintendent is provided at the farm as part of the compensation package and to provide after hour and weekend security at the farm.

B.S. degree in Agriculture or other related field or equivalent work experience is required. M.S. degree preferred. Experience in farm operations and management required and experience in apples, small fruits and vegetables preferred. Experience in supervising farm workers is required. A strong commitment to safety is also required. Ability to perform minor repairs of equipment and basic carpentry skills are preferred. Applicants must have an understanding of agricultural research and the needs of faculty doing the research. Applicant must have a Maine Class B driver's license or obtain one within 60 days of employment. Applicant must also have a Maine Research and Demonstration Pesticide Applicator's License or obtain one within 60 days of employment. Must be able to wear a respirator. Must have the ability to lift 50-60 lbs. loads several times daily. Excellent oral and written communication skills are also required.

The Superintendent works in numerous environments. While most work is performed at the Farm, some travel to the University of Maine campus is required as is some evening and weekend work. The job requires working out of doors in a variety of conditions, including heat, cold, dust, snow, and mud. The job also requires the operation of agricultural equipment. Pre-employment physical and appropriate background checks required.

Candidates should send a letter of application, a resume, copies of academic transcripts, and the names, addresses, and phone numbers of four professional references to Ryan Kuhl, Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station, 5782 Winslow Hall, Orono, Maine 04469-5782. Review of applications will begin on June 25, 2004 and will continue until a suitable candidate is found. Salary Range $30,000 - $34,000.

The University of Maine is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer. Women and minorities are strongly urged to apply.

A Member of the University of Maine System

 

 

Sincerely,                                            
Glen

Published and distributed in furtherance of the Acts of Congress of May 8 and June 30, 1914, by the University of Maine Cooperative Extension, the Land Grant University of the state of Maine and the U.S. Department of Agriculture Cooperating. Cooperative Extension and other agencies of the USDA provide equal opportunities in programs and employment.

A member of the University of Maine System.  Where company or brand names are used, it is for the reader=s information. No endorsement is implied nor is any discrimination intended. Always consult product labels for rates, application instructions and safety precautions. Users of these products assume all associated risks.

If you are a person with a disability and will need any accommodations to participate in programs, please call the Highmoor Farm at 1-800-924-5258 to discuss your needs. Please contact us at least one day prior to the event to assure fullest possible attention to your needs.